Fisheries Instrument Choice under Uncertainty
نویسندگان
چکیده
This paper uses data from an actual fishery to construct a tractable, dynamic model to compare expected profit and its variance, optimal stock size, optimal harvest rate, and optimal fishing effort under different management regimes under uncertainty. The results provide a comparison of instrument choice between a total harvest control and a total effort control under uncertainty, an original method to evaluate the tradeoffs between profits and other criteria in a dynamic context, and insights regarding the relative merits of catch and effort controls in fisheries management. (JEL Q22, D81)
منابع مشابه
Output versus Input Controls under Uncertainty: the Case of a Fishery
The paper compares the management outcomes with a total allowable catch (TAC) and a total allowable effort (TAE) in a fishery under uncertainty. Using a dynamic programming model with multiple uncertainties and estimated growth, harvest, and effort functions from one of the world’s largest fisheries, the relative economic and biological benefits of a TAC and TAE are compared and contrasted in a...
متن کاملThe Effect Of Salvage Market On Strategic Technology Choice And Capacity Investment Decision Of Firm Under Demand Uncertainty
متن کامل
Robust Dynamic Optimization and Natural Resource Management: Numerical Methods and Fisheries Management
Most resource management problems exist in a setting of not only risk, but of Knightian uncertainty. That is, not only is the problem stochastic, the underlying distribution for this randomness is not known with certainty and is difficult to recover. When faced with such problems of uncertainty or ambiguity, many decision makers do not follow a simple subjective expected utility type behavior (...
متن کاملCorrelated Uncertainty and Policy Instrument Choice
For two decades, environmental economists have generally maintained that benefit uncertainty is irrelevant for choosing between price and quantity instruments, but that cost uncertainty matters, with the identity of the efficient instrument depending upon the relative slopes of the marginal benefit and cost functions. But, in the presence of simultaneous, correlated uncertainty, such policy ins...
متن کاملIndividual vs. Collective Quotas in Fisheries Management Under Uncertainty
Rights-based approaches (e.g., ITQs, TURFs, collectives/cooperatives) are increasingly popular throughout the world, but there is relatively little theoretical literature comparing individual vs. collective approaches. This paper presents a stylized model that allows for such a comparison in a context where there is harvest uncertainty (and hence the potential for risk sharing) as well as poten...
متن کامل